Chimney Advice · Macclesfield

Pointing Gritstone: Why Deep Recessed Joints Fail

A recessed joint looks crisp and traditional, but on a gritstone stack it is often the detail that lets water linger. Here is how joint depth, softness and finish work together.

★ 5.0 from 74 Google reviews
✓ Repointing, flaunching, leadwork & pots
✓ Fully insured
✓ Free written quotations
✓ Chester, Cheshire & Wirral
Home › Chimney Repairs › Chimney Repairs Macclesfield › Pointing Gritstone: Why Deep Recessed Joints Fail
The short version
  • A deeply recessed joint makes a ledge under every stone, and the ledge holds water.
  • Mortar should be softer and more open than the gritstone, never harder.
  • Wide joints are filled in layers and pinned, not packed in one thick slab.
  • Finish is kept slightly back from the edge of the stone, not smeared over it.
  • Dark shadow lines and grit on the flags suggest the joints are emptying.

What a recessed joint does to a wet stone

Pointing on stone is judged by how it handles water, not by how it looks from the pavement. A joint finished well behind the face of the stone forms a small shelf under the stone above. Rain that runs down the wall drops into that shelf, sits there, and is drawn sideways into the bed of the stone and back into the wall. On a sheltered brick stack that might matter very little. On a gritstone stack taking weather off the hill it matters a great deal.

The deeper the recess, the longer the water stays. A joint that is cut back and left shadowed also shades itself from the sun and the wind, which are the two things that dry a wall. So the mortar and the stone beside it stay damp for longer than they should, and the first parts to suffer are the arrises of the stone and the face of the mortar itself.

Flush or very slightly back is the usual aim: a joint that sits close enough to the stone that water runs across it and on down the wall, without being spread over the face of the stone. The difference between those two things is only a few millimetres, which is why it is so easy to get wrong when pointing is done quickly.

Why the mortar must be softer than the stone

Gritstone is hard, but a wall is not a single piece. It moves a little with temperature and moisture, and the joints are where that movement is taken up. If the mortar is harder than the stone, the stone takes the strain instead, and you see arrises spalling off beside a joint that looks perfectly sound. Softer mortar sacrifices itself first, which is what you want, because mortar is the cheap and replaceable part of the wall.

A hard cement mix also tends to shrink away from the stone as it cures, leaving a hairline gap along both edges of the joint. Water gets into that gap by capillary action and cannot easily get out. This is a common reason why a stack that was repointed fairly recently looks worse than the neighbouring ones whose lime mortar is older. Our guide to Repointing a Chimney: Why the Mortar Mix Matters More Than the Finish sets out the thinking behind a sensible mix, and the same principles apply to stone with a little more room for judgement on sand and lime content.

Softness is not weakness. A properly made lime-based mortar is a sound, long-lived material when it is filled and cured properly. What fails early is mortar that was too wet, too thick or put on in a frost, not mortar that was gentle on the stone.

Filling, pinning and finishing a wide joint

Joints on gritstone range from a hairline to the width of a thumb or more, and the wide ones cannot be treated like the narrow ones. A thick slab of mortar filling a wide gap shrinks as it dries and cracks across its middle. The remedy is to fill in layers, letting each firm up before the next goes on, and to push slivers of the same stone into the wider beds as the mortar goes in. These pinnings carry some of the bulk, reduce shrinkage, and keep the mortar from becoming one flat plane.

The last layer is brought up close to the stone and then finished back by a small amount from its edge, which leaves the stone standing proud enough to shed water. It is brushed rather than trowelled smooth, so the sand in the mortar shows and the surface is open to the air. A shiny, ironed-in finish is a warning sign, because it is both too dense and too thin, and it tends to come off in sheets within a couple of winters.

Raking out for all of this is done by hand with a plugging chisel and not with a disc, because a disc leaves a narrow, squared slot that can chip the stone either side and cannot reach the irregular shape of a rubble joint. How far back the old mortar is cleared depends on how deep it has actually failed, not on a fixed figure, and sound mortar further in is left alone.

Signs the joints are emptying, and what to ask for

From the ground, with binoculars, look for shadow. A dark line where the mortar has retreated behind the face, a stone with a visible gap under it, a bed where a pinning has dropped out: these tell you the wall is losing its protection. Grit and small slivers of mortar on the path or in the gutter below mean the process is happening now rather than at some point in the past.

When you are getting a quotation, it is reasonable to ask how the old joints will be removed, what the new mortar is based on, how the wide joints will be filled, and how the finish will sit in relation to the stone. A good answer is specific. A vague one, or a promise to point it all flush with a grinder in an afternoon, is worth questioning. Our guide to What Should Be on a Chimney Repair Quotation? covers the rest of what a written quotation should state.

If you are looking at stone stacks in chimney repairs in Macclesfield and cannot tell whether the pointing is sound, describe what you see or send a photograph taken from the garden. Please do not climb up to check, as the stack is at the highest point of the roof and the ground beneath it is rarely forgiving.

When deep joints are already there

Many stacks have already been pointed too deep, sometimes more than once, with each repair cutting a little further in. The honest assessment is to look at how much sound stone edge is left to bond to. If the arrises are intact, the joints can usually be raked clean, filled in layers and brought forward to a sensible depth. If the edges have crumbled, the repair has to work with what remains, and that is a conversation to have on site once the scaffold is up.

Where the wall is in worse shape than pointing can address, the choice may move towards partial rebuilding, and our guide to Repoint, Rebuild or Remove? How the Decision Gets Made sets out how that decision is reached. Either way, the aim is a stack that sheds water from its face and lets the wall breathe, not one that is merely tidy.

Not sure what you are looking at? Describe it and we will tell you what it is likely to be — 07464 259566, WhatsApp, or Evensbuddy@yahoo.com. If water is coming in now, please call rather than email.
FAQs

Common Questions

How deep should the old mortar be raked out of a stone stack?
Only as far as it has actually failed. Loose, powdery or hollow-sounding mortar is cleared back to something firm, which is often a good deal deeper than the surface. Sound mortar behind it is left in place, because cutting everything out to a fixed depth damages the stone and weakens the wall for no gain.
Is a recessed joint ever correct on stone?
A slight set-back from the edge of the stone is normal and helps it shed water. What fails is a deep recess that makes a shelf under every stone. The distinction is small in size but large in effect, so it is worth asking how far back the finish will sit before any work starts.
Why does new pointing sometimes look pale and chalky at first?
Lime-based mortar dries and carbonates slowly, so it begins lighter and any patchiness evens out over time. A pale, slightly rough surface is normal and a good sign that it is open to the air. A hard, glossy finish that looks instantly uniform is more likely to be dense and unsuitable for old stone.
Can I fill the gaps myself with a tube of filler?
We would advise against it. Gun-applied filler seals the joint face and traps moisture behind it, and it does not bond to damp stone in any lasting way. It is also work at height on a stack, which should be done from a scaffold by someone who can see the whole joint, not from a ladder.
More Advice

Other Chimney Guides

More from the Macclesfield chimney series, then the wider guides.

Where We Work

Chimney Repairs Across Cheshire & the Wirral

Every town has its own page, written around the stacks that are actually on the roofs there. Start with the main chimney repairs page.

Customer Reviews

What Our Customers Say

5.0
★★★★★
74 Google reviews
★★★★★

“Excellent work replacing ridge tiles, repointing chimney and repairing flashing. Also fixed other broken tiles. Clean and tidy job. Would definitely recommend.”

Neil
★★★★★

“The guys did a great job in repairing our chimney. They were reliable, friendly and efficient. Buddy kept me in the loop throughout the whole process and I would not hesitate to use Roofline again!”

Hollie Furnival
★★★★★

“Highly recommend. Very quick and efficient. Great communication. Went above and beyond to work the weekend to complete the work that needed to be done. Very happy with the results.”

Karen Jones

Leave Roofline Solutions a Google review →

Free Quotation

Tell Us About the Chimney

Describe what you can see and roughly where you are, and we will come back to you — usually the same day. If water is coming in now, please call instead.

Prefer to talk? Call 07464 259566 · WhatsApp 0044 7464 259566 · Email Evensbuddy@yahoo.com

Find Us

Roofline Solutions, Elton, Chester

We cover Chester, Cheshire, the Wirral and Flintshire from Elton, just north of Chester.

Where We Are

2 Manley View
Elton
Chester
CH2 4QF

Almost all of our work happens at your property rather than here, so please call before travelling.

Opening Hours

Monday – Friday — 24hrs — Emergency Call-Outs
Saturday — 8:00 – 19:00
Sunday — 8:00 – 19:00

Weekday emergency call-outs are answered around the clock. Weekend cover is 8:00 to 19:00.