“Excellent work replacing ridge tiles, repointing chimney and repairing flashing. Also fixed other broken tiles. Clean and tidy job. Would definitely recommend.”
NeilA hip line that ends at a chimney asks a lot of a few cut tiles and a little mortar. Here is how the junction is built, where it tends to fail, and what a lasting repair looks like.
A hip is the sloping line where two roof planes meet at an outward corner. It is finished with hip tiles bedded along it and capped where it joins the ridge. Usually the hip and the chimney are well apart. On some roofs they are not: the stack stands close enough to the hip line that the hip tiles have to stop short of the brickwork, run alongside it, or be cut to turn around its corner. That is where an ordinary run of tiles becomes a detail, and details are where roofs leak.
There are two common arrangements. In the first, the hip ends against the side of the stack, so the last hip tile butts the brickwork and the lead has to catch whatever water that tile sheds. In the second, the stack sits just beside the hip and the hip tiles pass it with a narrow gap, so the corner of the brickwork, the hip bedding and the tiles on both planes all meet in one small space. Neither arrangement is wrong. Both leave less room for error than a stack standing in the middle of a plain slope.
On a roof that is hipped on every side, as many of the interwar semis in chimney repairs in Bebington are, every plane is leaning toward the same few places. Rain that lands on the hip tiles and the tiles beside them does not stay put. It runs to the lowest point, and if a stack is in the way, that point is the junction. The hip is also a line of weakness in its own right, because the bedding along it is exposed to weather from two directions at once.
Hip tiles are traditionally bedded in mortar, with the mortar kept back slightly from the exposed edge so that it sits in shade rather than being washed. Many are now also held by a mechanical fixing, such as a clip or a nail through the tile into timber, because mortar alone slowly loses its grip. Beside a chimney the hip tile cannot always be a full-length piece. It is cut to fit, and the cut end is the part that causes trouble, since it leaves a short, thin unit with very little bearing on the bedding beneath it.
The cut tiles on the roof planes either side follow the same logic. Where a plain or interlocking tile is trimmed to meet the hip and then the stack, the leftover piece is often small. A small tile is easy to dislodge, and the temptation is to bed it solid in mortar and move on. Mortar in that position cracks as the roof flexes with the seasons, lets go of the tile, and leaves a gap that looks tiny from the garden but is a direct route for water onto the underlay and battens.
Not every gap is a fault. A deliberate gap, such as the air path under a dry-fixed ridge or the space left so lead can move, is part of the design. A gap stuffed with foam, soft mortar or sealant is a different matter. Foam fixes nothing and holds water against timber. Sealant skins over, splits at its edges as it ages and hides the problem instead of curing it. You can often tell the two apart by whether the filling looks like part of the roof or like something added later.
The commonest fault is the end of the hip bedding losing its grip. The last tile before the stack takes the push of water from both sides, and the mortar under it is the first to crumble. Once that has happened the tile can rock, and a rocking hip tile lets rain run down into the roof space along the very line it was meant to seal. It is not unusual for the tile to look perfectly straight from below while being loose enough to lift by hand.
The second fault is a flashing that has been asked to cope with the geometry and cannot. Lead has to be dressed over the covering on both planes and tucked into the brickwork, and at a hip those two planes meet at an angle, so the lead has to turn a corner. If it has been cut and patched, with a seam in the worst possible place, or finished off with tape, it opens at the corner first. The resulting leak tends to show near the chimney breast or in the angle of a bedroom ceiling, and it is easily blamed on the stack itself. Our guide on Is It the Chimney? Working Out Where the Water Is Getting In explains how to tell the difference.
Third comes movement. The stack, the hip timber and the rafters beneath do not all move at the same rate, and over time a gap can open between the brickwork and the nearest tile. Mortar spread across a moving gap will not stay there. Daylight at the hip in the loft, a hip tile that has slipped out of line with its neighbours, or a straight line of moss growing along the hip beside the stack are all signs that water has been sitting in that spot.
A proper repair begins by lifting the loose tiles back to sound bedding and finding out how far the trouble goes. If the hip timber and the underlay beneath are sound, the tiles can be re-bedded with mechanical fixings where the system allows, and the tiny cut pieces replaced with ones large enough to hold. Where a tile has been cut too small to fix well, it is better to rearrange the course so that the cut falls somewhere with proper bearing, even if that means adjusting a tile or two further along.
The lead is then dressed to suit the corner. That means separate pieces where they are needed, a soaker or cover formed for the hip instead of bent to fit it, and a top edge chased into a mortar joint and wedged rather than smeared over. Where the pointing around the stack is also worn, it is done in the same visit. Because the hip, the flashing and the stack sit so close together, each repair disturbs the one beside it if they are done separately. Our Lead Flashing or a Cement Fillet? How to Tell Which You Have guide explains why lead, not a mortar fillet, is the right finish.
Please do not go up to look. A stack on a hip is at the highest and most awkward part of the roof, and the covering is not safe to walk on. If you can see a slipped or loose hip tile from the ground, send us a photograph or describe it, and we will arrange a free written quotation. What Should Be on a Chimney Repair Quotation? sets out what a quotation for this kind of work should say.
More from the Bebington chimney series, then the wider guides.
Every town has its own page, written around the stacks that are actually on the roofs there. Start with the main chimney repairs page.
“Excellent work replacing ridge tiles, repointing chimney and repairing flashing. Also fixed other broken tiles. Clean and tidy job. Would definitely recommend.”
Neil“The guys did a great job in repairing our chimney. They were reliable, friendly and efficient. Buddy kept me in the loop throughout the whole process and I would not hesitate to use Roofline again!”
Hollie Furnival“Highly recommend. Very quick and efficient. Great communication. Went above and beyond to work the weekend to complete the work that needed to be done. Very happy with the results.”
Karen JonesDescribe what you can see and roughly where you are, and we will come back to you — usually the same day. If water is coming in now, please call instead.
Prefer to talk? Call 07464 259566 · WhatsApp 0044 7464 259566 · Email Evensbuddy@yahoo.com
We cover Chester, Cheshire, the Wirral and Flintshire from Elton, just north of Chester.
2 Manley View
Elton
Chester
CH2 4QF
Almost all of our work happens at your property rather than here, so please call before travelling.
Monday – Friday — 24hrs — Emergency Call-Outs
Saturday — 8:00 – 19:00
Sunday — 8:00 – 19:00
Weekday emergency call-outs are answered around the clock. Weekend cover is 8:00 to 19:00.